Island Legal Info
Welcome to Island Legal Info!
Insurance Articles
•
•
•
•

Home
:: About Us
:: Contact Us
:: Article
:: Reports
:: Links
:: Site Map

Related Links

Goods In Transit Insurance

Hgv Courier Insurance

Haulage Insurance

Fleet Courier Insurance

Car Warranty
Supreme Court Decides Against Grokster In File Sharing Decision
By Richard Chapo


The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled peer-to-peer sites such as Grokster, Kazaa and Morpheus can be held responsible for copyright infringement by their users. In a rare 9-0 decision in favor of Plaintiff MGM, the Justices held that a business distributing technology with the active intent of promoting copyright violations could not escape liability for subsequent copyright infringements. Although unanimous, the ruling is a strained effort to isolate file sharing from other industries.

In arguing their position, Grokster had relied on previous rulings regarding VHS technology. In a 1984 case, the Supreme Court ruled the makers of VHS recorders could not be held liable for copyright piracy by users of the machines. The Court specifically ruled that VHS and any other technology with "substantially non-infringing uses" could not be held responsible if individuals illegally taped movies or shows off of television. Indeed, lower courts had ruled in favor of Grokster using the VHS ruling as precedent. So, what`s the difference between the two technologies?

In a somewhat tortured reasoning, the Justices distinguished the two cases by focusing on the "intent" of the companies. If a company distributes a technology with the intent that it be used by third parties for copyright infringement, then it is responsible. "Intent" is shown by a company making a "clear expression" of such intent or taking affirmative steps in said direction.

Writing the opinion, Justice Souter explained:

"There is no evidence that Grokster?made an effort to filter copyrighted material from users` downloads or otherwise impede the sharing of copyrighted files,"

He further explained,

"The company showed itself to be aiming to satisfy a known source of demand for copyright infringement, the market comprising former Napster users."

No Nail In The Coffin

The entertainment industry is trumpeting the end of file sharing. This ruling is no such thing. To understand the impact of the ruling, a brief discussion of legal procedure is necessary.

The Supreme Court decision does not find Grokster liable for anything. Instead, it simply reverses a lower court ruling that Grokster could not possibly be found liable. As a result, the case will return to the trial court and eventually go to trial. In the trial, the Plaintiff will have to prove that Grokster distributed file-sharing software with the intent that it be used for copyright infringement. Proving such a case will not be easy since ?intent? is a vague concept.

In Closing

The decision of the Supreme Court provides the entertainment industry with a basis for pursuing file sharing companies. Is file sharing at an end? Not likely.

For more information about this article and/or the author visit http://www.sandiegobusinesslawfirm.com

For more information, news and articles see:

Courier Insurance - Courier Insurance
...arcels being sent might be quite costly or important. Losing such document or parcels can mean huge losses for some people. Therefore,Courier Insurance has become an important consideration for any one using mailing services. It is not uncommon for people to lose their mail before it reaches a desired destination. We make sure that your mail is covered sufficiently so that if you happen to lose it while it is on its way, you will be compensated. Many people may not see this as a necessary step until they experience a loss. So, why wait for it to happen to you? Get your insurance now and save yourself from huge losses. ...
Visit Courier Insurance...

Gap Insurance - Gap Insurance
...w what gap insurance is? I know that I had never heard about this type of insurance before until it was brought to my attention recently. The gap insurance covers the deprecation on a car in the event of it being stolen and never recovered. How does it work you might wonder and do you need to take it out if you have outstanding finance on the vehicle? Say you have ten thousand pounds worth of car finance on your car but when it gets stolen the insurance company says it`s only worth eight grand. It means you`ll have to find the extra two thousand pounds to pay off the finance company. If you take out gap insurance on the car, this amount will be covered, so you don`t have to find any additional money to pay off the debt. Most people buy cars and decide to keep them for a set amount of time so they know how much fina...
Visit Gap Insurance...

Hgv Courier Insurance - Hgv Courier Insurance
...nsuranceis a very different type of insurance that you would normally purchase for a delivery business. So there are now insurers who specialise specifically in more complex insurance policys, they are experts in business insurance; therefore they will be able to advise you on all your insurance needs, to make sure you are completely covered, leaving no room for mistakes. The following is a list of the specifications that you may need to include in any haulage insurance cover and what can be potentially covered with the correct policy: Legal liability for injury or death to any other individual, including any such passengers. Legal liability for damage to outside property. Legal costs can be fully covered with the Insurers consent, in connection with an insurance claim against your policy. Your own damage (subject to any excess). Vehicle replacement, in the event of an accid...
Visit Hgv Courier Insurance...

Car Gap Insurance - Car Gap Insurance
...ever heard of car gap insurance until recently. I suppose unless you buy a car on finance you might not know about such policies. As I understand it the car gap insurance covers you in the event of a car being stolen and never recovered or one that is deemed a total loss by the insurers. If you still owe money on the car to a finance company then the gap insurance will pay off the difference between what the insurer says the car is worth and what finance you have left on it. Some of the policies will even leave you with some money to use as a deposit on another car. It`s, probably something that many people would never even consider when they take a car out on finance. If the insurance company decides that the car is worth less than you thought it might be when it is deemed a total loss then you could have to stump up the money to pay off the bal...
Visit Car Gap Insurance...
Click For More Detailed Information on:
my local legal info ::my cover pro online ::cover online ::legal pro info ::juridical 4 u info
Copyright © 2003-2012. All Rights Reserved.


Valid CSS!